How to Be an Effective Instagram Influencer

Especially if you don’t have 100,000 followers!

I remember when I hit the most exciting milestone on Instagram.

It wasn’t number of followers, likes, or comments. My account was nothing other than the product of a lot of hard work. I didn’t do a big collaboration, or get featured by anyone big.

All that happened was that a brand sent me free stuff in exchange for promoting it on my Instagram page.

I was officially an “influencer.”

Influencer: the individual whose effect on the purchase decision is in some way significant or authoritative. — Cambridge English Dictionary

This was what I’d been working for as long as I’d started thinking about running an Instagram account. It was the first step to making my dream job — being a stay-at-home cat-mom/blogger — reality.

It took me ten months to get to that first milestone. But the second time was a lot faster.

Here’s what I learned.

1. 5,000 followers is not a real milestone.

Photo by Jakob Owens on Unsplash

If you look into becoming an influencer, you’ll see people quoting all kinds of numbers of followers you need in order to be a “Real Influencer.”

Some people say 5,000, some people say 10,000, but all of them are touted as being some kind of magic number. Once you hit that number of followers, brands will see you as a “Real Influencer” and flock to collaborate with you.

The truth is anyone can be an influencer from around 1,000 followers, or perhaps even less. I did it with 2,500 followers but I wish I’d tried to start sooner.

Remember, the point of being an influencer is to sell people stuff. Brands used to focus on bigger Instagram stars (like Kylie Jenner) because as they had the biggest following and therefore the biggest chance for one of their followers to see their idol consuming something, and want to consume it too.

But stars like Kylie Jenner have a relatively low engagement.

What’s engagement?

Engagement is calculated as the number of likes + number of comments, divided by total number of followers.

The Kylie Jenners of the world may get three million likes — but with over 120,000,000 followers, that’s only 2.5% engagement. The relevance is low.

People like me, with less than 10,000 followers, tend to have around a 10% engagement rate. Our community interacts with us much more.

And we’re much cheaper. I was happy to promote this brand for free products.

It’s a win for marketers, to reach their ideal customer effectively and cheaply.

2. Be proactive

Photo by Tom Plouff on Unsplash

Ideally, of course, I would have thousands of brands messaging me, clamoring to collaborate.

Spoiler alert: I don’t.

Instead, I have to reach out to them.

I found brands of cat treats, cat toys, cat food, all kinds of cat paraphernalia on Instagram. I carefully crafted a message, laying out my offer.

The ingredients of the message:

  • The reasons we were a great fit
  • My proposed post
  • My follower demographic information

That’s all I needed. I sent a message out to a few brands my cats loved and sat back to wait.

Within a few hours, a brand got back to me, asking for my address to send me some new stuff from their Christmas line.

3. Stick to your message

Photo by Ryoji Iwata on Unsplash

The reason this tactic worked so well is because I put a lot of research into my outreach. My proposed campaign made sense to brands.

My audience demographics were perfect for the brands I messaged. The brands were on Instagram, so messaging them via that medium was a good method. They weren’t too big, but they weren’t too small either — the perfect size for an account of my follower count.

Most importantly, they sold products I think my audience would love. I looked into brands that would see my audience as their ideal customer.

I know my audience well. I’ve interacted with many of them, and at such a small number of followers, I’ve built a real community. What that means to brands looking for influencers, is that my audience are willing to trust me and respect my opinions on products. That’s lucrative for them — and later down the road, for me.

What’s the takeaway?

After the first time I reached out to a brand successfully, I was thrilled. This was the first step down the journey of being a stay-at-home cat-mom/blogger.

It took me ten months to get to that point. But I did the same thing again just one week later.

Once you get your methods down pat, you can easily start to expand and grow. And who knows? Maybe soon, someone will actually pay me money to post a cute picture of my cats.

Astrid and Chumbo on Instagram

Want my four-day email course on how to make money by writing Medium? Sign up to my mailing list here.

Biology MSc. Psychology nerd. She/her. Get my FREE 5-day Medium Starter Kit to make money writing about what you love:

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store